Political bookworm environmental impact of ebooks vs. While theres not a great argument to be made that reading a book on an ereader is preferable to reading a printed book, the environmental impact is something that does make ebooks superior to the printed word. Since theres not much research out there, it may be years before we understand the impact of tech devices on young readers. Life cycle analysis home institute of the environment. In the interesting and heated discussion in the post about the future of ebooks, it was raised that the environmental benefits of ebooks are one of its major advantages. Environmental impact analysis, by jim popolow, 041414 this 14minute video provides an excellent animated overview of the issues from tree to paper how its made, by arabtech, 0530 short video. If the book was published 20 or more years ago and is still around, its going to have the lowest carbon footprint of all. Theory and practice describes the various pieces of knowledge necessary to speak the language of eia and carry out eias focusing on a variety of environmental issues, including impacts on environmental components, like air, water, soils, land, noise and biological environments. The good, bad and the ugly sides of ebooks and kindles. They save space and thus transport and co2 per kg when it comes to distribution.
Weve already taken several glances at where e books stand out so well aim for a different approach today. A new study analyzing the amazon kindle electronic book readers impact on the environment suggests that, on average, the carbon emitted over the life of the device is offset after the first year of use. Negative environmental impact are ebooks more green. Environmental impact assessment natural heritage management guidance for competent authorities, consultees and others involved in the environmental impact assessment process in scotland a handbook on environmental impact assessment further copies available from. Not in my back yarders acronym laced with environmental responsibility. Manufacturing rechargeable batteries and computer components has a very large impact. If you read in bed, an ebook may be a good option as many readers come with builtin reading lights. One study highlighted that reading ebooks on the amazon kindle, for example, is only more green having read 23 books on the device. An impact can be described in terms of its magnitude and significance, terms to be dealt with more in detail in section 7. The second edition developed many issues of growing importance in this fast.
Below are a few pros and cons of jumping into the ebook revolution. Sharing distributes the environmental impact of a book over a whole community and promotes reuse over new production. Environmental education and education for sustainability. While it was necessary to have a variety of assumptions in order to perform this analysis, these same assumptions caused. Thats the beauty of a good book well cared for and the green movement as a whole. Recently ive detected a certain eco smugness from ebookworms whove. Well cover some fresh angles rather than rehashing the. Are ipads and kindles better for the environment than books. Organized into 15 chapters, the book provides engineers with the tools and methods. Guardian, amazons ebook sales have actually surpassed their printed book sales with.
The fact that its illegal in 50 states and the district of columbia to toss your ereader into the trash it contains hazardous wastea. Its not just buying e books that matters, said the reports author, emma ritch, of san franciscobased cleantech group. A new study analyzing the amazon kindle electronic book readers impact on the environment suggests that, on average, the carbon emitted. They hardly need any light when it comes to reading. However, as reported in an article in the new york times in 2010, journalists goleman and norris found that one. Environmental education and education for sustainability some south african perspectives by c. In terms of the effect on the climate, the emissions created by a single ereader are equal to roughly 100 books. It is particularly relevant especially in comparison to the impacts of the traditional publishing industry. However, if youre an avid reader who spends more than 30 minutes a day reading the news, the print edition results in a lower environmental impact than reading online 28 kilograms of co2 per year, per person for print versus 35 kilograms per year, per person for online reading. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading environmental impact assessment. Like music downloads, you ll never actually be able to resell electronic books. The more ebooks read on a single ereader, the greater the potential offset vs. When you seek to reduce your impact on the environment, you normally look to reuse as much as possible. History of environmental education, both internationally and in south africa.
The advantages of ebooks versus traditional books top. Presumably, all the ebooks of freedom can be easily updated online, much like a software update. Once you break the 50 book threshold, you are getting your. Environmental impacts of e books, green press initiative, january 2011 with the growth in the number of ereaders and sales of ebooks, many have begun to question the environmental impacts of ereaders and e books. Well see how they stack up compared to traditional books. The production and use of paper has a number of adverse effects on the environment which are known collectively as. E books vs printed textbooks protect environment posted on april 17, 2016 by lelin sun nowadays, with the rapidly increasing amount of environmental problems faced with human beings, people started realizing they should pay attention on environmental protection. Should i stop buying paper books and use an ereader instead. Environmental impact assessment eia and environmental impact statement eis. Debating paper vs electronic reading ignores problems that affect everyone. Yet, the negative environmental impact of print books really stems from the rate at which one reads their print books. Advantages of physical books over electronic titles. Study paints kindle ereader a dark shade of green cnet.
In the last several years, e books have become a mainstay and a powerful trend in the publishing industry. Book lovers are opting for both so we are going to delve into the pros and cons of each and their carbon footprint. In todays article, well look into the pros and cons of the new ebooks. An analysis by the cleantech group finds, when used to. Lets do the math for ourselves and see what the possible advantages of ebooks are over traditional books. This study showed that, in addition to the paper used, the way books are bought and distributed, including possible personal transportation, can significantly affect the total environmental impact of paper books. These are easy to use and won t get in the way like the lights attached to actual books do. According to one lifecycle analyses of printed books versus ereaders, the energy, water, and raw materials needed to make a single ereader is equal to that of 40to50 books.
Whatever electronic devices you use to store and read ebooks, such as a kindle paperwhite, ipad or smartphone, they can all easily store thousands of ebooks. An even better option is to walk to your local library, which can spread the environmental impact of a single book over an entire community. That is one of the many environmental benefits of digital publishing and reading. A study of the us book industry for a single year 2006 estimated that.
Find the top 100 most popular items in amazon books best sellers. Currently e books make up a relatively small portion of the overall book market and about 9% of the trade book market. Or would it be better for the environment if we all read books digitally on. With readers, the main pollutant is the manufacture of the battery and the screen. A common oversight amongst the general population when weighing the environmental impact of the ereader and print book would be the generalisation that ereaders are environmentally more friendly simply due to the amount of ink and paper they save. Should i stop buying paper books and use an ereader. Printed book an environmental analysis rit scholar. When talking about the books vs ebooks debate, often youll hear people say that ebooks and ereaders help protect the environment.
The waste of energy, water and paper caused by pulping so many books must be considerable by comparison if a genuine comparison is even possible. Price is a clear factor affecting e book consumption, with 52 percent of u. All of these factors can significantly change the environmental impact of news reading. The book vs ereader argument really centers around the co2. According to one lifecycle analysis of printed books versus ereaders, the energy, water, and raw materials needed to make a single ereader is equal to that of 40 to 50 books. So if you care about the environmental impact of your reading medium, remember that it is not a binary question of book vs ebook. Information can be obtained without leaving your desk. Paper versus digital media environmental impact green. Books make it easy to find something truly special, even if the cover is a bit worn or faded. Scottish natural heritage publications section battleby redgorton perth ph1 3ew t. Before analyzing the environmental impact of increasing numbers of e books specifically at boston college, we wanted to understand the environmental impact of e books as a whole. This is a project i did for school, and i thought i would share it with anyone who was interested.
Although their production requires resources, electronic books are kinder to the environment. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. As the number of users per book increased, the data suggested that the printed book tends to have less of an environmental impact. The bookprinting industry causes untold damage to the environment, both. When talking about the books vs ebooks debate, often youll hear people. One of the biggest advantages of ebooks is the fact that they require no trees to create them. According to a study from the royal institute of technology in sweden, an ebook begins to compensate for a print book when at least 33 digital works with around 360 pages have been read.
You might want to mention that many libraries now loan out e books. Parents are conflicted, too 68 percent prefer that their 6 to 8yearolds read print books, scholastic found. When books ordered via the internet were sent by postal services directly to the end consumer, the climate change impact was lowered. The environmental impact of growing numbers of ebooks in. By comparison, a book made of dead trees can last hundreds of years. Acidification, with only one user per book, the kindle may have less environmental impact. This is obviously an ecofriendly option that both reduces cost and lowers environmental impact. E books versus printed books is an infographic video that compares e books and printed books. Ive just bought a kindle ereader and, looking at all my shelves of books at home, am left wondering which has the smaller environmental footprint paper books or ebooks f wilson, by email. Environmental justice encompasses the fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people regardless of race, class or colour with respect to the development, implementation and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations and policies that could negatively impact their lifestyles. Dont be misled about paper versus electronic books.
Though these are valid questions, hopefully some background information will lead to a greater appreciation of this issues importance. So in conclusion if an ereader owner reads fewer than 50 books on their ereader it would have had a lighter impact on the environment. Probably the biggest advantage of ebooks over real books is that they weigh absolutely nothing. Are reading ebooks on ereaders environmentally friendly. Stephen lowman makes an important contribution to the ongoing dialogue about the impact of ebooks vs. Despite the facts, you might be asking yourself, why should i care about the environmental impact of printed books vs ebooks.
243 991 464 944 1588 1532 814 71 1195 1364 587 33 1628 690 429 368 1651 1154 254 508 491 710 1631 440 460 978 541 1031 1278 679 1139 1237 990 920 1103